Magic Trackpad Review

These days there is a lot to be excited about in the world of Apple. First off, rumors are abound regarding a 7 inch iPad to be released by Christmas. Or is that a 7 inch iPod Touch? LOL. Bad jokes aside, I did get the opportunity to test out Apple’s Magic Trackpad for a couple weeks now. And the verdict is in: I like it. I actually like it a lot.

Disclaimer: I have had very little personal experience using Apple’s new line of glass trackpads with their multi-gesture commands. I almost exclusively work on my 3.5 year old MacBook and my aluminum iMac so I have not had the chance to use the new trackpads for an extended period of time. Because of this, I am going to review the Magic Trackpad and the multi-gesture functionality as well.
When I first heard about the Magic Trackpad, I was skeptical. Most people I know, including myself, don’t like using trackpads on laptops, especially for an extended amount of time. Aside from work, when I am home using my MacBook, I always hook up a wireless mouse. I work a lot with Logic (Apple’s professional recording software), and I find it really frustrating using my MacBook’s built in trackpad to make minor adjustments to audio tracks. So naturally, I rarely use the trackpad on my MacBook unless I am out and about with it. So when the Magic Trackpad came out, I dismissed the premise of the whole thing; I mean, why would I consider ditching my mouse to use a trackpad on my work iMac?

Well, the thought occurred to me as I was editing some images in Photoshop: perhaps using the Magic Trackpad would be similar to using something like a Wacom Tablet while using Photoshop. The Magic Trackpad could potentially make things a little easier for me while using Photoshop. Well, I got a Magic Trackpad and, well….It’s not any better than using my traditional USB mouse while editing in Photoshop. As a matter of fact, I find using the Magic Trackpad in Photoshop could be a little counter-intuitive as the Trackpad’s rotate function is a little sensitive and I find myself rotating the image unintentionally.

Aside from that, using the trackpad for everything else is amazing! And here are the main reasons I love using the Magic Trackpad over my mouse.

Pros:

1. Expose – Being able to switch between Applications with a horizontal four-finger swipe is great as well as clearing the desktop and showing all open windows. This is one of my favorite things about the Magic Trackpad.

2. Scrolling – Two finger scrolling is one of those things that is just way easier and accurate than using a scroll wheel on a mouse. It’s simply more precise and allows me to do a simple gesture instead rolling a scroll wheel.

3. Comfort – This one is a little tricky. I have grown so accustomed to using a mouse that when I first used the Magic Trackpad it was really uncomfortable to use. I felt the muscles on top of my hand strain as I had to constantly hold all fingers up off the trackpad while leaving one finger on. After the first day of using the trackpad, I was ready to dismiss it. But when I got in the next day, my hand gravitated to the trackpad. I wasn’t feeling any strain and using the mouse again felt uncomfortable. What?!?!?! Just after one day of use, I was just about fully accustomed to using the trackpad. It just started to feel right and the mouse just started to feel wrong.

4. Size – There is enough real estate on this device that using it does not feel like you are using a laptop trackpad. It’s not too big that it takes over your desk, and its not too small.

And here are a few things I don’t like about the trackpad:

Cons:
1. Learning Curve – If you are one of those people that absolutely hates using a trackpad, this probably won’t work for you unless you devote a day or two to exclusively using the Magic Trackpad. Also, using Expose with the various finger swipes takes a little getting used to.

2. Rotate and Zoom Functions – As I said before, when using the trackpad with Photoshop, I found my self unintentionally rotating the image when I was trying to zoom in. Additionally, trying to zoom in inside a web browser is a little more tricky than I would have hoped.

3. Spaces – I am one of those people that loves using spaces. I have dual monitors and use 9 spaces. With my mouse, I mapped the Spaces function to my scroll wheel button. This is super convenient. So when I used my Magic Trackpad, I was at a stand still…how do I activate Spaces with my Magic Trackpad? I can’t. Apple simply left out the ability to map Spaces to a gesture. I would have loved to use a four-finger right swipe to activate Spaces, but I can’t. I had to map spaces to my F5 key. This may seem like a minor thing to most people, but as much as I use Spaces, I feel like including this as an option would have been the right thing to do.

Here is the verdict. I love using the Magic Trackpad, but it’s not perfect. I still have my mouse hooked up to my computer, so I would say that I use the Magic Trackpad about 75% of the time. The Magic Trackpad is not a necessary peripheral by any means, but if you did own one, you would most likely like it a lot…and use it a lot. Web browsing with this device is awesome given the two-finger scrolling. Expose works very well with this device. So, though nice and convenient, I feel that the Magic Trackpad is not going to be a perfect alternative to the mouse. But If you are using both a mouse and this device, you are set.

I give Apple’s Magic Trackpad 3.5 stars out of 5.

Written by Keith
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

This entry was posted on Monday, August 23rd, 2010 at 9:24 am and is filed under Author Posts. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

 

 

See iResQ Reviews at Bizrate.com
   
iResQ
15346 S. Keeler St.
Olathe, Kansas 66062 USA

1-888-447-3728

© 1994-2013 ResQ Systems, LLC. All rights reserved.
Please read our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy before making your purchase.

Formerly known as ipodresq, macresq, powerbookresq. iResQ is pronounced "irescue" or "i rescue"

*Information on our 24-hour policy is located in our FAQ section.

iResQ is not affiliated with Apple Inc., and is an independent service and repair entity. All Apple logos used on this site are a trademark of Apple Inc..

Apple, the Apple logo, iPod, iPhone, iBook, PowerBook, MacBook, iMac, Mac Pro, MacBook Pro, and iPad are trademarks of Apple Inc.,
registered in the U.S. and other countries. ResQ Systems, LLC, D.B.A.

Android is a trademark of Google Inc.. The Android robot is reproduced or modified from work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.